The timer relieves some of the symptoms but does not
address what I think is the underpinning problem.
For to relieve the problem I think we need to ponder
upon the Game Master's play style and make the
necessary (and minor) adjustments.
Once we understand her play style, we will understand
her expectations.
Once we understand her expectations, we will understand
the necessary adjustments to our own play style.
The Game Master's play style
If we can find ourselves on the same page as the Game Master,
then we can find our efforts being more fruitful.
It has not been so much of a problem to this point because
all from our challenges have been relatively minor and simple.
The challenge now before is more complex and intricate.
There is nothing simple about it.
If we are to prevail, we must take it on its terms.
We are vested with a great amount of power but we do not have
the power to dictate the terms of the nature of the world.
We must understand just how much power the Game Master gives up
to us.
We have a lot of power.
If we do not know how to well wield this power, then it can be
said that we have too much power.
But I do not want to give up this power.
We have the power to determine the story that unfolds.
We have the choice of where we go and how fast or slow we get
there.
All that she does is locate Points A and B then set up a
barrier somewhere in the middle.
All that we need to do is knock it down and arrive at Point B.
We are not on a rail road going where she wants us to go.
Neither can we ignore or avoid the barriers.
The reason why we cannot ignore or avoid them is because they
are organised and focuses for the sole purpose of acting against
our characters.
Therefore we must be more organised and more focused than the
barriers we face.
So the picture emerges that what we do and the choices we make
matter more than anything else to the outcomes.
We can choose to prevail or we can choose to fail.
The immediately obvious question is how to prevail?
The simple answer is a paraphrase of what many have
said: failing to prepare is preparing to fail.
I think it was Abraham Lincoln who said if you give him
six hours to chop down a tree then he will spend the first
four sharpening the axe.
If we prevail when we prepare the next immediately obvious
question is how to prepare?
As stated, we need to be organised and focuses so that we may
meet the world on its terms.
The Game Master has not hidden any secrets from us and has
stated at different times in her own posts and musings on
being a Game Master that planning is indispensable.
Furthermore we have been showed exactly how to go about
planning.
If this is good enough for the likes of Dwight Eisenhower,
then it is good enough for the likes of us is something
the Game Master
has said to me.
Eisenhower, to paraphrase, said that plans are worthless but
planning is indispensable.
Planning
Going over what the Game Master has said about planning I
have found it unwieldy and I think anyone else who read it
came to the same conclusion.
The result is that it was ignored and we are seeing the results
of this right now in our game.
So I intend to boil it down to its barest essentials at this time
with the goal of making it more acceptable.
Setting and reaching goals
A goal without a plan is just a wish.
—Antoine de Saint Exupéry
The Game Master's comprehensive list just mentioned was about
at its core the setting and reaching goals.
This is essentially what our characters are doing.
They are setting goals and they are attempting to
reach them.
For to reach them, they need planning.
A plan is a coherent set of action items which are designed for
to bring about some desired end condition.
What this requires is an understanding of the current condition
and a definition of the desired end condition.
Then all that is needed is the identification and definition of
a sequence of action items most likely to lead from start to end
conditions.
In regards to our game there are two very important aspects of
planning we must focus on—this is not coming from me, it is
coming from the Game Master.
The first aspect are the unknowns and assumptions and
the second aspect are the action items.
These aspects are here considered in turn.
Unknowns and assumptions
It has been said by others as well as the Game Master
than our characters' greatest enemy are unknowns
and assumptions.
These represent their weaknesses that their foes will
exploit.
It is a rule of nature and it is one we must heed and
meet nature on its own terms.
If we reasonable address this aspect of planning then
our efforts will bear fruit and the impartial dice will
determine the outcome of any confrontation.
If we fail to address them then the world will brutalise
our characters; we fail and imperil our characters.
We do not have to be perfect.
The Game Master has mused in her writings that if we put
in the effort then the barrier will be adjusted such that
we have a chance to knock it down with our planning.
In other words, if she has thought of something that we
have not thought of but we have made the effort to know
the unknowns and operate assumption free, then the things
we missed will not be allowed to exploit our miss.
They will be eliminated as if they never existed or will
be non-critical unknowns and assumptions.
As stated already here and elsewhere, the Game Master sees
her main role as Game Master as the one who puts up barriers
for us to knock down as we go for the things we want to go for.
Let us ask ourselves which is easier to accomplish:
to knock down a barrier when we know the materials that make up
the barrier and do not have to assume that our hammer is
sufficient or not knowing the materials and assuming
that our hammer is sufficient to knock it down?
Action items
An action item is an atomic and measurable unit of effort.
Compiled together, action items define the planning output.
They are the steps toward attaining the objective: the steps
from the start condition to the end condition.
They are the sequence of events most likely to bring about
the desired end condition.
They are atomic because they must be concise and easy to
measure.
They are measurable because it is necessary to know victory
when it is seen.
They are measurable because it is necessary to continuously
measure progress and know either that you are going on the
determined and correct
path you set out on or that you are needing to alter
the original path you set out on.
The result of being atomic and measurable means they cannot
be abstract expressions.
They must be concrete expressions.
We have seen how not well the Game Master deals with
abstract expressions and concepts.
When we asked for a timer using some abstract expressions
she beat us over our heads until a concrete expression was
supplied.
We would be wise in the definitions we create for action
items to avoid abstractions.
She sees abstractions as necessarily obscuring a part of the
concrete truth or reality.
And as a result they are nothing more than unknowns and
assumptions.
And as a result of that they should not be allowed in our
calculations.
As Tolkien wrote, to paraphrase The Hobbit,
it is folly to keep a living dragon
out of your calculations when you are living near one.
At its core this what planning is about.
It is an open-ended process until the goal is attained.
Actions are never taken in the Void and so the execution
of a plan must be measured and assessed constantly.
There is no other way to know if you are in the correct
course or ought to change your course.
Process
If we boil down the long comprehensive list supplied once
upon a time by the Game Master, then we might see the
following emerge.
- Identify a goal.
- Determine the current state.
This means to gather and centralise information and intelligence.
This means identifying and dealing with the critical unknowns
and assumptions.
- Determine the desired state.
- Identify and define the sequence of events most likely to
bring about the desired state.
- Identify, define, and assign the action items which will
bring about the sequence of events.
- Continuous measurement and necessary adjustments to the
execution of the action items.
Conclusion
So this is what we know.
Abstractions are dangerous to our characters' well
being.
Concrete expressions which address unknowns and
assumptions, while not having to be perfect, will
be good to our characters' well being.
By doing so we minimise our weaknesses and therefore
minimise our opponents' options for striking at
us.
Everyone from Æsop to Sun Tsu has taught this.
If we develop concrete action items which produce a
sequence of events we believe the most likely to
attain goals will mean attainment is most likely.
If we do not then we will not.
Planning is what we need to do about our way forward.
If we fail to do so we will continue to be brutalised
by our own lack of organisation, focus, and coherence.
It is a simple adjustment and solution.
To summarise the options available to us as I see them.
- Start organising and planning our actions.
- Find another game.
- Ask the Game Master to adopt a different play style.
If the last option, then we need to make sure that we come
with concrete rather than abstract expressions of what it is
we want. We have seem a couple of times now that the Game
Master is more than willing to give us what we ask her to give
to us.
But we have to be clear for two reasons.
First, it is like asking a djinn from a lamp for a wish.
You have to be very careful what are you asking for.
Second, any change could be a significant departure from
her comfort zone so the more precise our request the easier
for her to transition.
But I would ask whether we ought to tear her from her comfort
zone when we really do not seem to me to be outside our own
or even to leave our own?