I gave to the Game Master some questions about the events of our session with Galina's gladiatorial debut. I have decided to include the response verbatim without making any alterations to the content. Then I will draw my conclusions about what we can say about the world and what the means for our characters.
Game Master's notes
First an axiomatic statement about the game world is necessary to establish the context of this scenario. Money is like power, you either have it or you don't. Those that don't, want it. Those that do, want more of it. This creates a world which is fundamentally unscrupulous whenever either are the question. Because the arena is a question of at least money if not also power then the people involved will be unscrupulous. It does not here much matter than the company running the games in which Galina will participate is itself a company which is scrupulous except that once the people involved decide to be unscrupulous they are accepting a certain degree of risk. This is because cheating tarnishes the company’s reputation and so the company deals with cheaters harshly. While the company does have some responsibility for fairness, the Player Characters are responsible for themselves and cannot rely on the world to operate in their favour—and indeed it often does not. This is the context for Galina's gladiatorial debut in the game (and any other encounter or scenario going forward).
Rooted in this axiom is the fact that the game is going to be rigged unless the Player Characters emphatically demand for and secure a fair game. For to give them this opportunity, a few clues that something is amiss will be required. Those clues are here enumerated:
- The gnome will verify that Galina is a freelancer who lacks company representation, a lawyer, and experience with the politics of the arena. He will use this to measure how likely he believes are his chances that he can cheat her.
- The gnome will attempt to play head games and get inside Galina’s head and talk about how losing is not so bad so long as the crowd is won. This is true enough, but the gnome’s free advices are not intended to help Galina do anything but accept an early defeat in the arena—that is, not ask too many questions when she does lose early.
- The gnome will not offer to explain the opponents which Galina will face. He will couch this in terms of what is good for the games and the crowd. This is true enough that it is good for the games and the crowd, so here his position is not unreasonable. He is well aware of this and hopes to use it to disarm any attempts to demand a schedule. If the Player Characters are emphatic, then he will reveal what ought to be the schedule. And if he determines that he can cheat, he will be lying. Otherwise, things will go as planned and no one is the wiser.
- The gnome will not conclude any formal agreement about this, and he will not even bring up the various topics of arranging agreements about weapons and so forth. If the Player Characters are emphatic, then he will acquiesce to making just one copy of the agreement and keep it for himself. He will burn it at the first opportunity. If the Player Characters demand two copies or more—then he will determine that cheating is not here an option and things will go as planned and no one is the wiser.
The gnome will, if he decides to cheat, swap the opponents of Round Four with the opponent of Round One and then use Galina's quarantine period as his opportunity to secure bets against all odds that a gladiator will lose in the first or second round. Most gladiators breeze through these rounds, so betting against them seems to be foolish. There are always those willing to make foolish bets. Something about parting fools and their money.
If we get to this point, then the Player Characters will realise that something is amiss only when it is too late and the fighting has begun. The intention here is to create tension, suspense, and a sense of urgency rooted in the fact that cheating is occurring. It is also to create an opportunity for the Player Characters to exploit and improve their position and condition. Ironically, the gnome is being honest when he says a loss can be better for a career and a reputation than a victory. Some folks will approach Galina after being cheated and offer her some opportunity but what is made of this is ultimately going to be what the Player Characters make of it. If they choose inaction, then the opportunity will fade and be forgotten.
Mechanically, the fight was play tested several times and given Galina's sick combat bonuses at only Experience Level Three, they all went rather well for her. If the actual encounter goes so well, it could lessen the sting of being cheated. If it goes poorly, then it could cause problems. We are definitely entering dangerous waters because it is necessary that while the Game Master is screwing over Player Characters that the Players do not themselves feel like they are being screwed over. The Players must trust the Game Master that Karma is unfailing and that what is being done is not an assertion of the Game Master’s power, rather it is the presentation of an opportunity for more thanks to this unfair fight than would have been available after a fair fight. This ought to be kept front of everyone's mind.
My conclusions
In addition to reading and thinking about this response, I went back and re-read several of the things the Game Master has written about the topic of being a Game Master and approaching the game. It seems to me that two axioms about the game world can be derived:
- The nature of money and power are such that you either have them or you do not have them.
- Those who do not have them or do have then, will seek to get or grow them at the expense of scruples (and that means other people).
If the Game Master says these axioms exist, then it must be possible for us to discover them and to see them. If we cannot, then we can tell the Game Master that they do not exist. Although our characters have not lived through much adventure, they have lived through some. So I think about two adventures and I look for these axioms.
In the first advdenture I am thinking about, our characters obtained them and had a claim on them already when the bandits appeared and tried to rob the characters of their prize. In other words, there are thieves who will wait for someone else to do the hard work and then ambush them in an attempt to steal the fruits of their hard work. This happened when our characters explored the mystic misty swamp to get the valuable black mold for the alchemist in Aracho and when they leave the swamp, the bandits made their move.
In the second adventure I am thinking about, our characters and the gnome were racing each other towards them and the gnome was willing to fight unfairly to win the race against our characters. In other words, nobody has the claim and the first one to them keeps them. Until someone comes along and takes it from them.
What went wrong
If our approach to the game world is not the same as the Game Master's, then things like this will occur. Things like this occur when we do not keep the same axioms top of mind that the Game Master keeps top of mind. The ultimate and last word in the characters' well-being is in the characters themselves. We must not rely on the world to care about characters, because the world does not care. And I re-read several of the things the Game Master has written and about game playing style, this jumps out immediately at me. We forgot what has been clearly shown to us.